Minnesota Sues Exxon, Koch over Climate Change
24 Junho 2020 - 6:45PM
Dow Jones News
By Christopher M. Matthews
The Minnesota attorney general sued Exxon Mobil Corp., Koch
Industries and a top oil-and-gas trade group Wednesday, alleging
they have for years deceived consumers about the effects of climate
change.
Attorney General Keith Ellison said Exxon, three Koch companies
and the American Petroleum Institute deceived the public about
climate-change science to protect their business interests and, in
doing so, violated Minnesota laws that prohibit consumer fraud,
deceptive trade practices and false advertising.
The lawsuit seeks an injunction barring further violations,
financial restitution for alleged damages to Minnesotans and an
order requiring the entities to fund a public-education campaign on
climate change. Mr. Ellison said the penalties could amount to
billions of dollars.
"This lawsuit is part of a coordinated, politically motivated
campaign against energy companies," Exxon spokesman Casey Norton
said. "The claims are baseless and without merit. We look forward
to defending the company in court."
A spokeswoman for API, one of the industry's largest trade
groups, also denied the allegations. A Koch spokeswoman didn't
immediately respond to a request for comment.
The suit is the latest targeting the oil industry over its
contribution to global warming and alleged deception about the
accuracy of climate-change science. Minnesota joins more than a
dozen states, cities and municipalities that have sued energy
companies on similar grounds.
The industry has fiercely contested the lawsuits, which have so
far not resulted in any verdicts against oil and gas companies.
In December, a New York state judge cleared Exxon of fraud
claims, saying New York's attorney general had failed to establish
that the oil giant had deceived investors about how it accounted
for the cost of future climate-change regulation. The verdict
capped a nearly three-week civil trial between the state and Exxon,
which had spent several years fighting the case.
A pair of climate-change-related lawsuits in California may be
headed for trial after the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
rejected arguments by energy companies in May, ruling that state
courts are the proper forum for the suits. The cases, brought by
the cities of Oakland and San Francisco, had previously been
dismissed by a federal judge, who was overturned by the appeals
court. The defendants in those cases -- Exxon, Chevron Corp.,
ConocoPhillips, BP PLC, and Royal Dutch Shell PLC -- are expected
to appeal.
In the Minnesota lawsuit, the attorney general alleged internal
climate experts at the companies issued warnings to executives
about global warming for years as the companies simultaneously
financed public relations campaigns that misled the public about
the risks of climate change.
"The fraud, deceptive advertising and other violations of
Minnesota state law and common law that the lawsuit shows they
perpetrated have harmed Minnesotans' health and our state's
environment, infrastructure, and economy," Mr. Ellison said in a
statement.
Write to Christopher M. Matthews at
christopher.matthews@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 24, 2020 17:30 ET (21:30 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.