US Senators Seek Delay On Rail Bill, Vow Broad Reform Package
01 Junho 2009 - 3:44PM
Dow Jones News
The Senate sponsor of legislation to strip the railroad industry
of antitrust exemptions on Monday asked to cancel a Senate vote on
his bill, saying he has reached an agreement to have it included in
other railroad legislation.
A key vote on the antitrust legislation was scheduled for
Tuesday.
Sen. Herb Kohl, D-Wis., said in a letter to Senate colleagues
that he has reached an agreement with Sen. John Rockefeller,
D-W.Va., to have the antitrust legislation included in a different
bill that would overhaul the regulatory agency that oversees rail
transportation.
The agreement resolves a dispute between the two senators that
emerged late last week.
Rockefeller, the chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee, had
been a supporter of Kohl's legislation but changed course last week
and urged the Senate to block final consideration of the bill.
Rockefeller said the antitrust bill would undercut his
legislation to overhaul the Surface Transportation Board, which
regulates rail competition.
On Monday, Kohl and Rockefeller said in joint letter that they
"are working on harmonizing our two efforts to produce a robust
reform package."
"This is a high priority for both of us and we are absolutely
committed to finding real solutions that can be enacted into law
this year," the senators said.
The rail industry has been adamantly opposed to Kohl's bill,
saying it would create considerable uncertainty in the industry and
discourage private investment.
Shippers, including companies in the energy, chemical and
agricultural industries, support the bill, complaining that rail
freight prices have been too high.
Four rail companies dominate the rail shipping business: Norfolk
Southern Corp. (NSC), Burlington Northern Santa Fe Corp. (BNI), CSX
Corp. (CSX) and Union Pacific.
Among other things, Kohl's bill would repeal legal provisions
that make certain railroad transactions exempt from review by
antitrust regulators and that allow freight railroads to engage in
collective ratemaking.
Rockefeller had criticized some provisions of Kohl's bill.
A senate staffer with knowledge of the negotiations between the
lawmakers said one controversial provision of Kohl's bill will
likely not be included in Rockefeller's legislation. That provision
would provide that in legal disputes, federal trial judges wouldn't
have to defer to the jurisdiction of the Surface Transportation
Board, whose oversight has been criticized as too friendly to the
railroads.
-By Brent Kendall, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-9222;
brent.kendall@dowjones.com