Health Discovery Corporation Issues Update on Challenges to Intel SVM-RFE Patent
17 Setembro 2012 - 10:15AM
Business Wire
Health Discovery Corporation (OTCBB: HDVY) has received
notification from the United States Patent and Trademark Office
that it intends to issue a re-examination certificate to Intel
Corporation following completion of the re-examination of Intel’s
Patent No. 7,685,077 entitled “Recursive Feature Eliminating Method
Based on a Support Vector Machine.”
During the re-examination, the USPTO agreed with the Company’s
assertions that the claims of the Intel patent read on the
Company’s prior art, meaning that the Company’s earlier patents
disclosed all elements of the Intel claims, rendering them
unpatentable. In response to rejection of the Intel claims, Intel
amended its original claims to include an additional step of
“storing the updated kernel data in the buffer to replace the
[prior] kernel data.” In the statement of reasons for
patentability, the patent examiner explained that although the
cited prior art computes modifications to the kernel data in
intermediate computations, they do not disclose storing the data to
replace the previous data. Based on this step alone, the patent
examiner determined that the claims were patentable and should be
certified as such.
The Company finds the examiner’s comments to be a clear
indication of failure to observe the standards for patentability
established under U.S. Patent Law. In particular, the
identification of a step that is inherent in the operation of every
computer as the basis for patentability evidences a lack of
understanding by the examiner of one or both of basic computer
operation and the duty of the Patent Office fully examine patent
claims in view of the known prior art before deciding that a patent
should be granted.
While disappointed with the examiner’s decision in the
re-examination, the Company draws encouragement from the fact that
the Patent Office agreed that all elements of the Company’s
patented SVM-RFE method are present in the Intel claims. A
fundamental principle of patent law is that the addition of one or
more elements to a patented claim does not avoid infringement. In
this case, Intel merely added a standard computer operation to the
Company’s SVM-RFE method. Furthermore, possession of a patent on a
series of steps does not avoid infringement of a patent covering a
subset of those steps.
The completion of the current re-examination opens the door to
moving forward with interference proceedings involving the
application that was filed by the Company to provoke an
interference with Intel. Initiation of the interference proceedings
had been placed on hold by the Patent Office pending completion of
the re-examination. The Company last week submitted a request to
the Patent Office that the interference now be allowed to
proceed.
An interference is an administrative proceeding within the
Patent Office through which a determination is made of who is
entitled to a patent when two parties make claims to the same
invention. Under current U.S. Patent Law, the first person to
invent an invention is entitled to a patent. An interference is
commonly provoked by submitting a new continuation application with
claims that were copied from an issued patent or published
application. If the owner of the continuation application can show
that they are entitled to an earlier priority date than the issued
patent, then the party with the issued patent must provide
persuasive evidence that they actually invented the claimed subject
matter before the earlier priority date of the other party. In this
case, the Company’s earliest application describing SVM-RFE was
filed in March 2000. Intel’s application for SVM-RFE was filed in
August 2005. The patent examiner who is examining the Company’s
continuation application has agreed that the claims of the
application are identical to those of the Intel patent and that
they are, therefore interfering. As a result, the Company is
confident that it will prevail and be declared the sole owner of
the SVM-RFE method when its claims are compared side-by-side with
Intel’s claims.
About Health Discovery Corporation
Health Discovery Corporation is a molecular diagnostics company
that uses advanced mathematical techniques to analyze large amounts
of data to uncover patterns that might otherwise be undetectable.
It operates primarily in the emerging field of personalized
medicine where such tools are critical to scientific discovery. Its
primary business consists of licensing its intellectual property
and developing its own product line of biomarker-based diagnostic
tests that include human genes and genetic variations, as well as
gene, protein, and metabolic expression differences and image
analysis in digital pathology and radiology. For more information,
see www.healthdiscoverycorp.com.
Forward-Looking Statements
This document contains forward-looking statements within the
meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995,
the accuracy of which is necessarily subject to risks and
uncertainties, including, without limitation, statements regarding
future performance, opportunities and investments, and anticipated
results in general. From time to time the Company may make other
forward-looking statements relating to other matters, including
without limitation, commercialization plans and strategic
partnerships. Actual results may differ materially due to a variety
of factors, including, among other things, the acceptance of our
approach to applying mathematics, computer science and physics into
the disciplines of biology, organic chemistry and medicine and our
products and technologies associated with those approaches, the
ability to develop or commercialize new drugs, therapies or other
products based on our approaches, and other factors set forth from
time to time in the Company’s Securities and Exchange Commission
filings.
All forward-looking statements and cautionary statements
included in this document are made as of the date hereof based on
information available to the Company as of the date hereof, and the
Company assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking
statement or cautionary statement.
Health Discovery (CE) (USOTC:HDVY)
Gráfico Histórico do Ativo
De Out 2024 até Nov 2024
Health Discovery (CE) (USOTC:HDVY)
Gráfico Histórico do Ativo
De Nov 2023 até Nov 2024