SUNNY
ISLES BEACH, Fla., Aug. 4, 2023
/PRNewswire/ --
Dear Fellow Unitholders,
As we stated in our last letter, we have reset our focus on our
core activism strategy. We have long believed that activism is the
best investment paradigm. We believe activism has served IEP
unitholders handsomely over the years, as shown by our long-term
track record. Let us look at the results if you purchased our IEP
depositary units in January 2000 for
$7.63 per unit. If you reinvested all
distributions in additional IEP depositary units and sold the units
on July 31, 2023, you would have had
a 1,623% cumulative increase, which translates to an annualized
return of 13%. We believe this compares extremely favorably to the
performance of the broad based indexes listed below over that same
period. Not only have IEP unitholders benefited based on our
activism efforts, but the other public stockholders of the
companies with which we have engaged through our Investment segment
generally were able, if they entered and exited such stocks at the
same times as us, to participate in the value creation alongside us
to the tune of billions of dollars.
Returns from 01/01/00
to 07/31/23
|
|
Annualized
Return
|
|
with
Dividend
|
|
Reinvestment
|
IEP
|
12.8 %
|
S&P 500
|
6.9 %
|
Dow Jones
|
7.4 %
|
Russell 2000
|
7.4 %
|
Nasdaq 100
|
7.1 %
|
Nasdaq
Composite
|
6.5 %
|
Berkshire Hathaway
A
|
10.0 %
|
Additionally, I believe it is compelling that if you purchased
1,000 IEP depositary units in January
2000, for $7.63 per unit and
elected to take all distributions in cash as they were paid, you
would have received approximately $76,000 in cash distributions and would have
still owned the 1,000 units.
As compelling as the above numbers are, they would have been far
more impressive had we not strayed over the past several years from
our activist methodology and shorted (hedged) far more than was
necessary. While we made money on the long side through our
activism efforts, our returns have been overwhelmed by our overly
bearish view of the market and related oversized short (hedge)
positions. Over the past six months, we have significantly reduced
our hedges. Going forward, we intend to stick to our knitting and
focus on our activist strategy while remaining appropriately
hedged.
The numbers above speak for themselves. Activism is the best
investment paradigm. The reason is simple – there is no
accountability in Corporate America. With many exceptions, most
CEOs are incapable of creating great businesses (or even improving
them) and the desire to empire build is rampant. Most CEOs are not
the best person for the job or even the most talented individual at
the organization. Rather, too often CEOs have risen through the
ranks because they were ho-hum, with the main skill of having not
been seen as threatening to their superiors. Those CEOs are
generally too busy playing at the proverbial country club to
realize what improvements can be made or what hidden jewels can be
unlocked.
Once a CEO ascends to their seat, it is extremely difficult to
remove them. CEOs, generally with the help of a few friendly
directors, are able to pack their respective board of directors
with cronies who are unwilling to challenge a CEO or hold them
accountable for their performance for fear of losing the prestige
and stipends that come with being a public company director.
Shareholders find it hard to hold management teams and boards of
directors accountable because there is no real corporate democracy.
For example, if a board is challenged by the company's own
shareholders, the board is able to use corporate funds (which
should otherwise benefit the company's shareholders) to defend,
entrench and enrich the board! Boards can hire overpaid legal,
financial and communications experts, with little regard to cost or
concern for the wishes of shareholders. These tactics are similar
to what occurred in feudalistic societies when peasants attempted
to overthrow their rulers, only to be met with highly-paid
mercenaries. Put simply, the deck is stacked against the
shareholder and the activist, and this explains why there is so
little activism today relative to the number of companies that
could benefit from it.
Even when a shareholder wages and wins an activist campaign,
boards can be so entrenched that it can take years to implement the
needed changes and unlock the value and/or hidden jewel.
HOWEVER, WHEN AN ACTIVIST IS SUCCESSFUL IN CHANGING THE BOARD OR
THE CEO, GREAT VALUE CAN BE UNLOCKED FOR ALL SHAREHOLDERS AND THIS
IS WHY OUR RECORD OVER THE LAST 23 YEARS HAS BEEN SO
IMPRESSIVE.
There are very few activist investors that have the capital
base, the will, the knowledge and the patience to improve companies
and increase shareholder value for all holders. We have done
precisely this many times, including at Forest Labs, Netflix,
Caesars, eBay, Herbalife, CVR Energy, Tropicana, Cheniere and
Apple, to name just a few. And we hope and believe that we will be
able to continue to do this.
We believe strongly that our current portfolio will yield
additional winners and generate significant upside ahead. Through
our activism we have become members of the boards of directors of
many of the companies that we are currently invested in. Most
recently, we gained board representation at Illumina, resulting in
the replacement of its Chairman and CEO. We believe that these
types of activist strategies will continue to meaningfully enhance
value for all shareholders.
We thank our many loyal unitholders that have communicated to us
over the last several months. We look forward to continuing to
focus on our activism strategy.
Sincerely,
Carl C.
Icahn
Caution Concerning Forward-Looking Statements
This release contains certain "forward-looking statements"
within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act
of 1995, many of which are beyond our ability to control or
predict. Forward-looking statements may be identified by words such
as "expects," "anticipates," "intends," "plans," "believes,"
"seeks," "estimates," "will" or words of similar meaning and
include, but are not limited to, statements about the expected
future business and financial performance of Icahn Enterprises and
its subsidiaries. Actual events, results and outcomes may differ
materially from our expectations due to a variety of known and
unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors, including risks
related to economic downturns, substantial competition and rising
operating costs; the impacts from the Russia/Ukraine conflict, including economic
volatility and the impacts of export controls and other economic
sanctions, risks related to our investment activities, including
the nature of the investments made by the private funds in which we
invest, declines in the fair value of our investments as a result
of the COVID-19 pandemic, losses in the private funds and loss of
key employees; risks related to our ability to continue to conduct
our activities in a manner so as to not be deemed an investment
company under the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended, or to
be taxed as a corporation; risks related to short sellers and
associated litigation and regulatory inquiries; risks related to
our general partner and controlling unitholder significant
influence; risks related to our energy business, including the
volatility and availability of crude oil, other feed stocks and
refined products, declines in global demand for crude oil, refined
products and liquid transportation fuels, unfavorable refining
margin (crack spread), interrupted access to pipelines, significant
fluctuations in nitrogen fertilizer demand in the agricultural
industry and seasonality of results; risks related to the success
of a spin-off of the fertilizer business including risks related to
any decision to cease exploration of a spin-off; risks related to
our automotive activities and exposure to adverse conditions in the
automotive industry, including as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic
and the Chapter 11 filing of our automotive parts subsidiary; risks
related to our food packaging activities, including competition
from better capitalized competitors, inability of our suppliers to
timely deliver raw materials, and the failure to effectively
respond to industry changes in casings technology; supply chain
issues; inflation, including increased costs of raw materials and
shipping, including as a result of the Russia/Ukraine conflict; interest rate increases;
labor shortages and workforce availability; risks related to our
real estate activities, including the extent of any tenant
bankruptcies and insolvencies; risks related to our home fashion
operations, including changes in the availability and price of raw
materials, and changes in transportation costs and delivery times;
and other risks and uncertainties detailed from time to time in our
filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission including our
Annual Report on Form 10-K and our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q
under the caption "Risk Factors." Additionally, there may be other
factors not presently known to us or which we currently consider to
be immaterial that may cause our actual results to
differ materially from the forward-looking statements. Past
performance in our Investment segment is not indicative of future
performance. We undertake no obligation to publicly update or
review any forward-looking information, whether as a result of new
information, future developments or otherwise.
Investor Contact:
Ted Papapostolou, Chief Financial
Officer
IR@ielp.com
(800) 255-2737
View original
content:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/carl-c-icahn-301893357.html
SOURCE Icahn Enterprises L.P.