Risks Related to our Intellectual Property and Technology
Licenses
We depend on our intellectual property, and our failure to protect
that intellectual property could adversely affect our future growth
and success.
Failure to protect our existing intellectual property rights may
result in the loss of our exclusivity or the right to use our
technologies. If we do not adequately ensure our freedom to use
certain technology, we may have to pay others for rights to use
their intellectual property, pay damages for infringement,
misappropriation, or other violation, or be enjoined from using
such intellectual property. We rely on patent, trade secret,
trademark and copyright law to protect our intellectual
property.
We previously licensed certain of our carbonate fuel cell
manufacturing intellectual property to POSCO Energy on an exclusive
basis in the South Korean and broader Asian markets, and pursuant
to the terms of the Settlement Agreement with POSCO Energy, we have
done so again, but this time on a limited, non-exclusive basis to
enable module replacement to POSCO Energy’s existing LTSA customers
only. (See the section above entitled “Business – License
Agreements—License Agreements and Settlement Agreement with POSCO
Energy” for more information with respect to the limited license
granted to POSCO Energy and KFC.) In addition, effective as of
June 11, 2019, we entered into the EMTEC License Agreement,
pursuant to which we agreed, subject to the terms of the EMTEC
License Agreement, to grant EMTEC and its affiliates a
non-exclusive, worldwide, fully paid, perpetual, irrevocable,
non-transferrable license and right to use our patents, data,
know-how, improvements, equipment designs, methods, processes and
the like to the extent it is useful to research, develop, and
commercially exploit carbonate fuel cells in applications in which
the fuel cells concentrate carbon dioxide from industrial and power
sources and for any other purpose attendant thereto or associated
therewith. Such right and license is sublicensable to third parties
performing work for or with EMTEC or its affiliates, but shall not
otherwise be sublicensable. Furthermore, on November 5, 2019,
we entered into the EMTEC Joint Development Agreement, pursuant to
which we agreed to grant EMTEC and its affiliates a worldwide,
non-exclusive, royalty-free, irrevocable, perpetual,
sub-licensable, non-transferable (subject to certain exceptions)
right and license to practice certain Company background
intellectual property (to the extent not already licensed pursuant
to the EMTEC License Agreement) for new carbonate fuel cell
technology in carbon capture applications and hydrogen
applications. We depend on POSCO Energy and EMTEC to also protect
our intellectual property rights, but we cannot assure you that
POSCO Energy or EMTEC will do so.
As of October 31, 2022, we (excluding our subsidiaries) had 129
U.S. patents and 251 patents in other jurisdictions covering our
fuel cell technology (in certain
cases covering the same technology in multiple
jurisdictions), with patents directed to various aspects of
our SureSource technology, SOFC technology, PEM fuel cell
technology and applications thereof. As of October 31, 2022, we
also had 40 patent applications pending in the U.S. and 107 patent
applications pending in other jurisdictions. As of October 31,
2022, our subsidiary, Versa Power Systems, Ltd. (“Versa”), had 29
U.S. patents and 87 international patents covering SOFC technology
(in certain cases covering the
same technology in multiple jurisdictions). As of October
31, 2022, Versa also had 7 pending U.S. patent applications and 21
patent applications pending in other jurisdictions. In addition, as
of October 31, 2022, our subsidiary, FuelCell Energy
Solutions, GmbH, had license rights to 2 U.S. patents and 7 patents
outside the U.S. (in certain
cases covering the same technology in multiple
jurisdictions) for carbonate fuel cell technology licensed
from Fraunhofer IKTS.
Some of our intellectual property is not covered by any patent or
patent application and includes trade secrets and other know-how
that is not able to be patented, particularly as it relates to our
manufacturing processes and engineering design. In addition, some
of our intellectual property includes technologies and processes
that may be similar to the patented technologies and processes of
third parties. If we are found to be infringing, misappropriating
or otherwise violating third-party intellectual property, we do not
know whether we will be able to obtain licenses to use such
intellectual property on acceptable terms, if at all. Our patent
position is subject to complex factual and legal issues that may
give rise to uncertainty as to the validity, scope, and
enforceability of a particular patent.
We cannot assure you that any of the U.S. or international patents
owned by us (including our subsidiaries) or other patents that
third parties license to us will not be invalidated, circumvented,
challenged, rendered unenforceable or licensed to others, or that
any of our owned or licensed pending or future patent applications
will be issued with the breadth of claim coverage sought by us or
our licensors, if issued at all. In addition, effective patent,
trademark, copyright and trade secret protection may be
unavailable, limited or not applied for in certain foreign
countries.